Imaginary frequencies

[mones19]

I am getting multiple imaginary frequencies due to methyl rotational modes.
I tried different functional/basis set and tightening the geometry optimization convergence but still imaginary frequencies persistently appear. What other options might solve the imaginary frequency issue?

[aerba]

Hi,

The presence of imaginary frequencies is a sign that the geometry is not a minimum of the potential energy surface (PES). In general, this may due to two main factors:

1) A somewhat loose overall numerical precision in the geometry optimization + harmonic frequencies calculation. Here, it seems that you have already explored a few parameters. We can distinguish between parameters governing the overall numerical precision of the SCF + forces calculations, and those that are specific to the evaluation of the Hessian:

1.1) Precision of SCF+forces

One may increase a bit the thresholds for the screening of two-electron integrals (TOLINTEG keyword), switch-off the bipolar approximation (NOBIPOLA keyword), increase the shrinking factor (SHRINK keyword), use a denser grid for numerical integration of the exchange-correlation term (see XLGRID, XXLGRID keywords), tighten the convergence criteria for the SCF (setting TOLDEE to 10 or 11 for instance), tighten the convergence criteria for the geometry optimization step (see TOLDEG and TOLDEX keywords).

1.2) Numerical evaluation of the Hessian

In many cases, a more numerically stable evaluation of the Hessian is achieved by use of a two-sided finite difference approach (rather than the default one-sided approach). This can be activated with the NUMDERIV keyword within the FREQCALC input block as follows:

FREQCALC
NUMDERIV
2
ENDFREQ

2) The presence of symmetry-constraints that prevent the optimizer to get to the minimum of the PES. If this is the case, removing symmetry constraints may be key to reach the minimum. This can be done by use of the SYMMREMO keyword (to be inserted in the geometry input block).